| BWMN Time |
| 11/21/2024 |
| 17:18 |
| News |
| new account |
| list users |
| Login: |
| Replays |
| Map DB |
| ICCup |
| Map Access |
| New map |
| Edit map |
 |
(4)MOTHY
| deadline to enter maps: 2011, 01, 01 (Year, month, day) |
| This MOTHY is for all non-2-player maps. As such the MOTHY will have two winners, which I think is fair since there\'s quite a few maps stretched over quite a long period. Again, this is not a Map of the Year, only a MOTM covering several months. |
Comments:
| freakling |
| Oh, thanks. Muuuch easier overview now. |
| Nightmarjoo |
| Yeah it was a good idea ~~ |
| freakling |
| Some thoughts and comments: - Windmill: Even with the colony I don't know how zerg's expected to defend here. Space could be better distributed, allowing a wider middle. - Tomorrow: I really fancy this one. I always kinda liked Katrina despite all its drawbacks and this pretty much fixes Katrina's issues. Maybe a bit too much snow for most players eyes, but hard to change due to the layout. I already pointed out all the minor flaws and LC has supposedly fixed them (picture needs update!). - Vapor: I really Hope Jungle finishes this. Depending on the outcome I think it'll be this one or Tomorrow for me. - Romantica: Well executed despite the boring look (which is partially caused by the tileset). Being the only 3 player map in the competition alone makes it interesting :P - Monument: Callow for-the-picture-map. Nothing more to say here. modified by freakling |
| LasTCursE |
| I give freakling's map a chance altho i would like for him to make it a little bit less of a mess ::D |
| Nightmarjoo |
| I don't like any of them ._> Windmill is unplayable pvz, else I'd probably vote for it (it needs to be properly FEable!). In Tomorrow it's too hard to flank a horizontal/vertical attack. If there were more paths to the middle (like, if the broken snow connecting the four plateaus was removed) I would consider voting for it. Escher Plane has no problems, but it's incredibly boring ._> Over-large mains suggest poor space allocation in Romantica. Zepretnaya Zona seems messy: particularly I don't care for the expo layout. |
| Nightmarjoo |
| Er nevermind about Windmill, I looked at the rest of the map and it's just unplayable period haha. |
| Freakling |
| Monument first place? Seriously? I could update Escher with interchanged positions of Minonly and 3rd-access-point, update Pyro with reduced gas values and some stuff in the middle... Why don't you like Razor or Vapor? modified by Freakling |
| Nightmarjoo |
| Obviously Monument is throw-away vote. Vapor looks unfinished to me. As it is now, it doesn't really give you anything that Shakras doesn't do better. I don't that you can't play teal vs purple in razor. In the other positions it seems like the map favours passive turtley play. Top right/bottom left seem useless, your almost semi-island third or a nat/main will always be a superior choice. The min onlys are kind of useless too. The nat looks weird. I don't see that the troy gates make a difference. And what's left is a fairly boring map. It's certainly not bad, it just seems to me to lack flair. |
| Freakling |
| C'mon, Marjoo. Throw-away votes suck. I can update Escher for you, won't be the most exciting map ever, of course, but some interesting island mechanic is not particularly incredibly boring, eh? And I thought about making the cliffed expos in Razor double gas. What would you say if I added some flavour to Pyro's middle and made all main gases 2k to force agressive expo play? Bizarre also looks like a ... bizarre ... vote. |
| Nightmarjoo |
| My votes are always subject to change. |
Add your comment:
You are not logged in. Log in to post.
 |